The story revolves around Lily and Oliver, who have lost their mother and their father, Jim, has a new girlfriend, Anna. Jim plans a camping trip with his girlfriend and children in order to help them bond with each other, but Lily and Oliver have other ideas and are afraid that Anna will replace their mom, so they play pranks on Anna, hoping to get scare her off.
The storyline is a bit predictable and addresses the conflicts that arise when family structures change due to the loss of a parent and spouse. The plot develops quite naturally and predictably, but it's not cloying in any way. The two child protagonists are well portrayed and their situation - having to deal with their father's new girlfriend is relatable. The rationale behind the children wanting to get rid of the girlfriend, Anna, is very touching; they don't want their father to forget about their mother, for whom they are full of love and longing. On the other hand, the love connection between Anna and Jim is a bit unclear. We don't see when they relationship goes from being just friends to something more, so that is confusing. The acting is pretty good, especially from the primary characters - Jim, Anna, Lily and Oliver. The "missing person" here is the deceased mom and wife, whose presence seems omnipotent in the memories of both the children and Jim. The repeated comments -- "Mom said" or "my wife used to say" --become an ominous drum roll in Anna's mind and beg the question of whether this man or his children are ready to move forward or not. It takes a complete meltdown before Jim finally steps up to the plate and addresses his children's poor behavior. It takes an all-out crisis to bring everyone together and realize that there is more to fear than the emotions they have been dealing with.
The camera work is quite good, with adequate lighting and a blend of camera angles throughout. I particularly like the use of animated line drawings at the opening of the film to indicate what is to come. That is heartwarming and lighthearted. I should point out that there is a spot around the 15 min mark when Jim and Anna are at night and the scene is too dark to see them. The setting includes multiple rooms in a middle class home and when they go camping, they are in a vehicle on the road and then in a wooded area. The background music is very non-intrusive gives a calmness to the film.
The theme of the film is about adjusting to new situations after the loss of a loved one and the difficulties it brings. In the end - love conquers all. There are a few unsafe situations that one would not children to replicate, like allowing Anna's hear to be hit by a branch and Oliver overeating chocolate to the point that he vomits.
I give Mum Said 4 out of 5 stars and recommend it for ages 8 to 12, plus adults. Reviewed by Xiangxi K. and Julie S., KIDS FIRST!
The story revolves around Lily and Oliver, who have lost their mother and their father, Jim, has a new girlfriend, Anna. Jim plans a camping trip with his girlfriend and children in order to help them bond with each other, but Lily and Oliver have other ideas and are afraid that Anna will replace their mom, so they play pranks on Anna, hoping to get scare her off.
The storyline is a bit predictable and addresses the conflicts that arise when family structures change due to the loss of a parent and spouse. The plot develops quite naturally and predictably, but it's not cloying in any way. The two child protagonists are well portrayed and their situation - having to deal with their father's new girlfriend is relatable. The rationale behind the children wanting to get rid of the girlfriend, Anna, is very touching; they don't want their father to forget about their mother, for whom they are full of love and longing. On the other hand, the love connection between Anna and Jim is a bit unclear. We don't see when they relationship goes from being just friends to something more, so that is confusing. The acting is pretty good, especially from the primary characters - Jim, Anna, Lily and Oliver. The "missing person" here is the deceased mom and wife, whose presence seems omnipotent in the memories of both the children and Jim. The repeated comments -- "Mom said" or "my wife used to say" --become an ominous drum roll in Anna's mind and beg the question of whether this man or his children are ready to move forward or not. It takes a complete meltdown before Jim finally steps up to the plate and addresses his children's poor behavior. It takes an all-out crisis to bring everyone together and realize that there is more to fear than the emotions they have been dealing with.
The camera work is quite good, with adequate lighting and a blend of camera angles throughout. I particularly like the use of animated line drawings at the opening of the film to indicate what is to come. That is heartwarming and lighthearted. I should point out that there is a spot around the 15 min mark when Jim and Anna are at night and the scene is too dark to see them. The setting includes multiple rooms in a middle class home and when they go camping, they are in a vehicle on the road and then in a wooded area. The background music is very non-intrusive gives a calmness to the film.
The theme of the film is about adjusting to new situations after the loss of a loved one and the difficulties it brings. In the end - love conquers all. There are a few unsafe situations that one would not children to replicate, like allowing Anna's hear to be hit by a branch and Oliver overeating chocolate to the point that he vomits.
I give Mum Said 4 out of 5 stars and recommend it for ages 8 to 12, plus adults. Reviewed by Xiangxi K. and Julie S., KIDS FIRST!
KIDS FIRST! Goes Local: Submit a review & win!
